Test Drive: 2010 Madza5 Touring

Addition of Mazda5 not a plus for lineup

Mazda5 a good idea that falls short in execution

2010 Mazda Mazda5

Full-size minivans are great, but they may be too much car for those with smaller families. One option is the Mazda5. There's room for up to six passengers, and the 5's smaller footprint makes it more maneuverable than the segment's larger offerings.

Mazda had a great idea — to create a smaller, higher-mileage, affordable vehicle called the Mazda5 with three rows of seats for those folks getting out of larger, lower-mileage and pricey SUVs.

A great idea that comes up a little short in execution.

Mazda5 is half a foot shorter and 2 inches narrower than a compact Chevy Equinox, though, in fairness, Equinox is more a midsize crossover posing as a compact to gain an edge in the latter segment. Smart move.

Still, the dimensions make the front-wheel-drive Mazda5 a snug fit, with decent but not lavish leg, head and arm room for second-row occupants. Not even that for those in the third row.

Second-row passengers can move their seat fore or aft, depending on whether anyone is sentenced to sit behind. Nice touch are the bucket seats in row two, with a small aisle between. Lower the seatbacks, and second-row seats also slide forward to create a small aisle to steerage.

Mazda5's short length makes it easy to slip into a parking space or whatever room is in the garage. But it greatly limits cargo space unless you fold the third row seats flat — in an instant when you pull the release straps.

Too bad the seats for driver/front passenger don't have longer tracks to slide farther from the steering column and dash. And front seats need longer bottom cushions for thigh support. No traveling long distances in comfort either, with the sparsely cushioned seats front-to-back and headrests that feel like bricks in rows two and three.

But hats off to whoever came up with the idea for the second-row seat bottoms that serve as hiding places. Lift the bottom on the passenger side to reveal a removable tray with dual cupholders that slips between the buckets to hold snacks and beverages. And the seat bottom on the driver's side lifts to reveal a space for a small purse or a few other items.

Mazda's DNA is zoom, but this machine acts like a distant relative. The 2.3-liter, 153-horsepower 4-cylinder lacks zip when leaving the stoplight, pulling into the passing lane or climbing inclines on the interstate. Of course, with a 21 mpg city/27 highway rating and the ability to hold six people, it's not meant to be a sprinter.

While an economy vehicle, handling is surprisingly well mannered. Stability and traction control help, along with good grip from the 17-inch all-season radials. though uneven road surfaces can make the Mazda5 a bit jumpy.

While controls are easy to see and reach, it could use a few more places to store things. The holder between the seats has an open top, as does the coin holder at the bottom of the dash to the right of the wheel and what appeared to be the cell phone and/or iPod holder to the left. A power plug and auxiliary plug are behind the gearshift along the floor.

Mazda calls this a multifunction vehicle rather than a crossover, wagon or minivan. Though the sliding side doors scream minivan, they are nice because they allow easy loading/unloading when someone parks too close.

Its two main attractions are mileage and price, with the Mazda5 starting at $21,250, yet blessed with a healthy list of standard equipment, including automatic climate control, power windows/locks/mirrors, AM/FM sound system with six-disc CD changer, power moonroof, rear-window defogger, anti-lock brakes and side-curtain air bags for all three rows.

The next-generation Mazda5 will bow in the U.S. at the Los Angeles Auto Show in December before going on sale early next year, though no word yet on whether a 2011 or 2012 model.

The Mazda5 needs a little more room, a little more power and a little more foam rubber in seatbacks and bottoms. Hopefully, those are on the "to do" list next year.

Read Jim Mateja Sunday in Rides. Contact him at transportation@tribune.com.
ct-rides-0221-mateja-mazda5-20100218
Luxury car picks » Luxury car picks Small & midsize SUV picks » Small & midsize SUV picks The world's most beautiful cars » The world's most beautiful cars 2012 VW Beetle: 'Pure, unadulterated fun' » 2012 VW Beetle: 'Pure, unadulterated fun' Concept cars: Winners & losers » Concept cars: Winners & losers Sports cars: Winners & losers » Sports cars: Winners & losers Eight Ferraris crash in Japan » Eight Ferraris crash in Japan Small cars: Winners & losers » Small cars: Winners & losers 360° panorama: L.A. Auto Show » 360° panorama: L.A. Auto Show A century of Chevy » A century of Chevy FBI's most-stolen cars » FBI's most-stolen cars Photos: Cars with decent fuel mileage » Photos: Cars with decent fuel mileage Buy Here Pay Here car dealers thrive amid hard times. » Buy Here Pay Here car dealers thrive amid... 2011 Frankfurt Auto Show » 2011 Frankfurt Auto Show The 2011 Mini Cooper S Countryman » The 2011 Mini Cooper S Countryman Small cars: Loaded but affordable » Small cars: Loaded but affordable The best SUVs for $29,000 » The best SUVs for $29,000 Dashboard designs » Dashboard designs Better engines, bit by bit » Better engines, bit by bit What does this button do? » What does this button do? Photos: Cars women like » Photos: Cars women like The cars they drove » The cars they drove Concept cars: New York Auto Show winners & losers » Concept cars: New York Auto Show winners &... Winners & losers: 2011 New York Auto Show » Winners & losers: 2011 New York Auto Show LoJack's most-stolen cars » LoJack's most-stolen cars Worst hybrid cars for the money » Worst hybrid cars for the money Photos: Insurer's best car values for 2011 » Photos: Insurer's best car values for 2011 Corvette Generations » Corvette Generations Road test: Three plug-in cars » Road test: Three plug-in cars Cheapest cars to insure for 2011 » Cheapest cars to insure for 2011 Photos: Best high-mileage cars for 2011 » Photos: Best high-mileage cars for 2011 Car stats: How numbers lie » Car stats: How numbers lie Tour the Chicago Auto Show » Tour the Chicago Auto Show Chicago Auto Show history » Chicago Auto Show history Photos: Auto show winners & losers » Photos: Auto show winners & losers Incredible! Car gets stuck in snow standing on nose » Incredible! Car gets stuck in snow standing... Photos: Cars of the 2011 Chicago blizzard » Photos: Cars of the 2011 Chicago blizzard Fast moves off car dealer lots » Fast moves off car dealer lots Photos: Next year's models » Photos: Next year's models Photos: Auto show concept cars » Photos: Auto show concept cars Top 10 ugliest car grilles » Top 10 ugliest car grilles Photos: 2011 Detroit Auto Show » Photos: 2011 Detroit Auto Show Best-selling cars of 2010 » Best-selling cars of 2010 Photos: 2011 Car of the Year finalists » Photos: 2011 Car of the Year finalists Detroit Auto Show Green Cars » Detroit Auto Show Green Cars Top 10 subcompact cars: November 2010 » Top 10 subcompact cars: November 2010 Photos: Gifts for drivers & car enthusiasts » Photos: Gifts for drivers & car enthusiasts L.A. winners & losers: Cars & convertibles » L.A. winners & losers: Cars & convertibles L.A. Auto Show: Concept Cars » L.A. Auto Show: Concept Cars <b>Photos:</b> Scenes from the LA Auto Show » Photos: Scenes from the LA Auto Show First Drive: 2011 Hyundai Sonata Turbo photos » First Drive: 2011 Hyundai Sonata Turbo photos Photos: A $109,000 car, but $0 for gas » Photos: A $109,000 car, but $0 for gas Bond cars. James Bond cars. » Bond cars. James Bond cars. Photos: New & intriguing 2011 cars » Photos: New & intriguing 2011 cars Top 10 dream cars » Top 10 dream cars Small and new: Fuel-sipping cars » Small and new: Fuel-sipping cars First Drive: 2011 Mercedes-Benz SLS AMG review & photos » First Drive: 2011 Mercedes-Benz SLS AMG... Auto models' last lap » Auto models' last lap Fast movers off dealer lots » Fast movers off dealer lots Minicar meetup: No small affair » Minicar meetup: No small affair 10 cars that refuse to die » 10 cars that refuse to die Photos: 2011 Mercedes-Benz E-Class Cabriolet » Photos: 2011 Mercedes-Benz E-Class Cabriolet Photos: Car couture » Photos: Car couture Pictures: New 2011 Harley-Davidson Models » Pictures: New 2011 Harley-Davidson Models First look: 2011 Ford Explorer » First look: 2011 Ford Explorer Vroom! The Top 50 TV and Movie Cars of all time » Vroom! The Top 50 TV and Movie Cars of all... Top 10 underrated new cars » Top 10 underrated new cars Photos: New 'Transformers 3' autobots » Photos: New 'Transformers 3' autobots Pull over for new cop cars » Pull over for new cop cars Photos: 2010 cars with best expected resale value » Photos: 2010 cars with best expected resale... Photos: Truck models whose time never came » Photos: Truck models whose time never came Two gear sets, no waiting: The shift to dual-clutch transmissions » Two gear sets, no waiting: The shift to dual-... Most popular used cars » Most popular used cars Best car brands » Best car brands