Test Drive: 2009 Toyota Corolla

Corolla at 40: A little wider, more solid

2009 Toyota Corolla

2009 Toyota Corolla

Engine: 1.8-liter, 132-h.p. 4-cylinder

M.P.G.: 27 city/35 highway

Base price: $15,350

This old fogey has survived more than 40 years since its 1968 U.S. debut in an industry not known for longevity. Corolla is still an econocar, but one that has grown from subcompact to compact dimension. For 2009 it swells by 2.4 inches in width, a reaction to larger hips, not bigger briefcases. Four-wheel ABS is standard in all models.

Prices & availability | Photos & reader reviews | Toyota special offers

The Toyota Corolla has survived more than 40 years since its 1968 U.S. debut.

That's a heck of a feat in an industry not known for its longevity. Toyota's reputation for quality and reliability, of course, helps keep the nameplate alive.

The 10th generation of the compact sedan is now in showrooms as an '09 model.

Corolla isn't the most fuel-efficient car in the Toyota stable. Prius, with its 48 m.p.g. city/45 m.p.g. highway, holds that title for Toyota and the industry. Corolla isn't even second best in mileage at Toyota. The subcompact Yaris is, at 29/35. Corolla with its 1.8-liter, 132-horsepower 4-cylinder and 4-speed automatic comes in third at 27/35.

But, unlike Prius, Corolla isn't saddled with a premium for the battery hardware that puts up the huge fuel savings—and that's Corolla's selling point: Good mileage and utility at a reasonable price.

While the name has remained the same, Corolla hasn't. Once the smallest and cheapest offering in the lineup—the position Yaris now holds—Corolla has grown to compact dimensions in response to the typical consumer econcar complaint: Love the car, but it's a tad too snug.

Corolla is offered in standard, LE, XLE, S and high-performance XRS versions. We tested the dressy XLE.

It sports new body panels that Toyota calls "lean and stylish." In truth the car is so traditionally conservative that the designers who did the original must have been brought back to create the 2009 body panels.

The car is roughly the same size as the previous generation except for 2.4 extra inches in width, a nod to the fact that some in the U.S. have buns of steel, most have butts and thighs of foam rubber. The dimension change brings much-needed stretch space in the cabin.

The trunk is huge as well. Tall grocery bags or large suitcases slip inside nicely. A very nice touch is the plastic tray in the corner that holds a couple gallon milk jugs to keep them from bouncing around. Rear seat backs fold when you pull the release lever in the trunk, but won't go flat unless headrests are removed.

While the added width creates more hip and elbow room, it didn't do anything for the legs, knees or heads of those in back. Kids will handle the space fine, adults not so much. Front or rear, the seats could use a little more padding back and bottom and the bottom cushions could be a bit longer for better thigh support in long trips. The cloth coverings stay cool in the summer.

The new 1.8-liter in the XLE, along with the standard, LE and S, has variable valve timing teamed with a 5-speed manual as standard, a 4-speed automatic as optional. It replaces the anemic 126-h.p. 4. But while blessed with a few more horses, there's still more groan than gusto when you push the pedal hard to pass.

For those who feel they must opt for a manual to get the most mileage, the rating is 27 m.p.g. city/35 m.p.g. highway with it or automatic.

A 2.4-liter, 158-h.p. 4 is available for oomph fans, but it's in only the performance XRS. While the majority of folks buy Corolla for mileage, a little more muscle would be appreciated. Perhaps in Gen 11.

The suspension is tuned for soft, economy-car ride and handling, which is why you'll experience some lean in corners. Take them at speed and you may hear the radials scrape pavement. Sadly, while four-wheel anti-lock brakes are standard in all models, stability control with traction control is a $250 option in all but the XRS, in which it's standard. Why not make it standard across-the-board to keep all the wheels firmly planted taking off from the light or in corners? Keeping the base price $250 lower just doesn't seem like a good enough reason.

And while attention was paid to the need to stop in panic situations, more needs to go into improving everyday braking—there's too much travel in the pedal. Most Corolla owners aren't concerned with zero- to 60-m.p.h. quickness, but all value a thrifty 60-to-0 time.

The XLE we tested starts at $17,550 and the goodies include side-curtain air bags, power locks/windows/mirrors, air conditioning, AM/FM radio with CD player and MP3 playback, keyless entry, power plugs in the console and under the center armrest, cupholders front and rear, dual glove boxes and digital clock.

In addition to stability and traction control, options on the test car included an all-weather package that added heated sideview mirrors and heavy-duty heater with a rear-seat duct for $150, cruise control for $250 and a JBL audio upgrade with XM satellite radio, Bluetooth with eight speakers and hands-free controls for $1,060. Navigation system is a new option, though it wasn't on the test car. Power seats aren't on any Corolla.



Read Jim Mateja Sunday in Transportation. Contact him at transportation@tribune.com.
chi-2009-toyota-corolla
Luxury car picks » Luxury car picks Small & midsize SUV picks » Small & midsize SUV picks The world's most beautiful cars » The world's most beautiful cars 2012 VW Beetle: 'Pure, unadulterated fun' » 2012 VW Beetle: 'Pure, unadulterated fun' Concept cars: Winners & losers » Concept cars: Winners & losers Sports cars: Winners & losers » Sports cars: Winners & losers Eight Ferraris crash in Japan » Eight Ferraris crash in Japan Small cars: Winners & losers » Small cars: Winners & losers 360° panorama: L.A. Auto Show » 360° panorama: L.A. Auto Show A century of Chevy » A century of Chevy FBI's most-stolen cars » FBI's most-stolen cars Photos: Cars with decent fuel mileage » Photos: Cars with decent fuel mileage Buy Here Pay Here car dealers thrive amid hard times. » Buy Here Pay Here car dealers thrive amid... 2011 Frankfurt Auto Show » 2011 Frankfurt Auto Show The 2011 Mini Cooper S Countryman » The 2011 Mini Cooper S Countryman Small cars: Loaded but affordable » Small cars: Loaded but affordable The best SUVs for $29,000 » The best SUVs for $29,000 Dashboard designs » Dashboard designs Better engines, bit by bit » Better engines, bit by bit What does this button do? » What does this button do? Photos: Cars women like » Photos: Cars women like The cars they drove » The cars they drove Concept cars: New York Auto Show winners & losers » Concept cars: New York Auto Show winners &... Winners & losers: 2011 New York Auto Show » Winners & losers: 2011 New York Auto Show LoJack's most-stolen cars » LoJack's most-stolen cars Worst hybrid cars for the money » Worst hybrid cars for the money Photos: Insurer's best car values for 2011 » Photos: Insurer's best car values for 2011 Corvette Generations » Corvette Generations Road test: Three plug-in cars » Road test: Three plug-in cars Cheapest cars to insure for 2011 » Cheapest cars to insure for 2011 Photos: Best high-mileage cars for 2011 » Photos: Best high-mileage cars for 2011 Car stats: How numbers lie » Car stats: How numbers lie Tour the Chicago Auto Show » Tour the Chicago Auto Show Chicago Auto Show history » Chicago Auto Show history Photos: Auto show winners & losers » Photos: Auto show winners & losers Incredible! Car gets stuck in snow standing on nose » Incredible! Car gets stuck in snow standing... Photos: Cars of the 2011 Chicago blizzard » Photos: Cars of the 2011 Chicago blizzard Fast moves off car dealer lots » Fast moves off car dealer lots Photos: Next year's models » Photos: Next year's models Photos: Auto show concept cars » Photos: Auto show concept cars Top 10 ugliest car grilles » Top 10 ugliest car grilles Photos: 2011 Detroit Auto Show » Photos: 2011 Detroit Auto Show Best-selling cars of 2010 » Best-selling cars of 2010 Photos: 2011 Car of the Year finalists » Photos: 2011 Car of the Year finalists Detroit Auto Show Green Cars » Detroit Auto Show Green Cars Top 10 subcompact cars: November 2010 » Top 10 subcompact cars: November 2010 Photos: Gifts for drivers & car enthusiasts » Photos: Gifts for drivers & car enthusiasts L.A. winners & losers: Cars & convertibles » L.A. winners & losers: Cars & convertibles L.A. Auto Show: Concept Cars » L.A. Auto Show: Concept Cars <b>Photos:</b> Scenes from the LA Auto Show » Photos: Scenes from the LA Auto Show First Drive: 2011 Hyundai Sonata Turbo photos » First Drive: 2011 Hyundai Sonata Turbo photos Photos: A $109,000 car, but $0 for gas » Photos: A $109,000 car, but $0 for gas Bond cars. James Bond cars. » Bond cars. James Bond cars. Photos: New & intriguing 2011 cars » Photos: New & intriguing 2011 cars Top 10 dream cars » Top 10 dream cars Small and new: Fuel-sipping cars » Small and new: Fuel-sipping cars First Drive: 2011 Mercedes-Benz SLS AMG review & photos » First Drive: 2011 Mercedes-Benz SLS AMG... Auto models' last lap » Auto models' last lap Fast movers off dealer lots » Fast movers off dealer lots Minicar meetup: No small affair » Minicar meetup: No small affair 10 cars that refuse to die » 10 cars that refuse to die Photos: 2011 Mercedes-Benz E-Class Cabriolet » Photos: 2011 Mercedes-Benz E-Class Cabriolet Photos: Car couture » Photos: Car couture Pictures: New 2011 Harley-Davidson Models » Pictures: New 2011 Harley-Davidson Models First look: 2011 Ford Explorer » First look: 2011 Ford Explorer Vroom! The Top 50 TV and Movie Cars of all time » Vroom! The Top 50 TV and Movie Cars of all... Top 10 underrated new cars » Top 10 underrated new cars Photos: New 'Transformers 3' autobots » Photos: New 'Transformers 3' autobots Pull over for new cop cars » Pull over for new cop cars Photos: 2010 cars with best expected resale value » Photos: 2010 cars with best expected resale... Photos: Truck models whose time never came » Photos: Truck models whose time never came Two gear sets, no waiting: The shift to dual-clutch transmissions » Two gear sets, no waiting: The shift to dual-... Most popular used cars » Most popular used cars Best car brands » Best car brands